Jump to content

PrinceBlueblood

Senior RP Staff
  • Content Count

    3,951
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    67

Blog Entries posted by PrinceBlueblood

  1. PrinceBlueblood
    I'll start right off by saying that I really do appreciate the staff trying to come up with something really cool. I know from my own RP experience that mega-events can be a lot of fun, both playing and running them. However, there have been a couple... shall we say, issues I've noticed in this year's Nightmare Night event. I'm not as frustrated as I was two days ago, when I posted a somewhat uncalled-for long and ranty comment on QuickLime's blog, so hopefully I can be somewhat fairer in evaluating what it was that didn't quite go right, at least in my opinion.
    The first thing, I will admit, is personal and subjective, but the fact is, I don't come to this site for Role Plays in that style. I have other sites where I go for RP's that are more adventurous or combative; Canterlot for me is a place for more relaxing, character-driven slice of life stuff. Mind, over the top sometimes, as befits its cartoon origins, but still in that mindset.
    That's important, you see, because the first thing you have to decide when writing a story is what kind of story you're going to write, sad, exciting, funny, etc. Everything else is designed around that. It's no different in Role Playing, or collective storytelling. All my characters were designed for the normal, WOE-style stuff; I hadn't had much opportunity to really think through what their capabilities in an invasion situation were, which made it difficult for me, and I think for quite a few others in the same boat, to strike a balance between being unreasonably effective and being a load.
    Of course, that brings me to the second point. Not everyone came into this event with the same expectations on what kind of story they wanted to write, and even in the framework of adventure stories, there are still different ways of setting things up. To get personal again, all the combat or adventure RP's I've been in had a basic assumption that all characters had been brought together to make a more-or-less equal contribution to a goal. Whether or not they got it was, in fact, dependent on their actions. Both they and their enemies went "all out," knowing the other would.
    Now, when we suddenly switched from Slice-of-life to Adventure, my entire mindset switched, too, even though I hadn't designed my characters for it, and neither had most of my fellows, for that matter. That wasn't true in all cases, however, leading to point number 3.
    There was a huge imbalance in the capabilities of each character versus the changelings. My older schoolcolt, for example, would probably not fare as well as a trained REA officer. But, I would feel that I was letting down the team if I didn't contribute, and I also would feel frustrated that others weren't either, even if it made in-character sense that they wouldn't. Again, this was because I was used to the idea that not making an effort would actually mean losing (even though that probably doesn't hold true here).
    As far as the actual fighting went, I still can't help but feel that it got to be a real mess at times. You generally had at least 10 players on the Pony side, and one staff member on the changeling side, with only one exception (The Invasion of Ponyville! thread). Now, this generally meant trouble in terms of god-moding, since a pony player's round might consist of between 15-20 posts, and even if a player didn't write in an automatic success, another might base their post off the assumption that they had. Naturally, the changeling player would think this unfair, since the players could overwhelm them in one round, so they had to write massive posts explaining why all of that didn't work. Of course, the pony players (this one at any rate) would think this unfair, because they put in multiple posts to accomplish nothing.
    This is generally why, in freeform combat RP's, a player cap and posting order really help smooth things along. Generally, a ratio of 5:1 of good guys to bad guys is about the maximum imbalance I would allow on the site I administer, just to keep arguments from arising.
    Again, though, this all assumes my own framework of combat/adventure RP's, and not every player when in with them. Some played the thing for laughs, others were content to explore the psychological breakdowns of pastel equines under stress until rescued by an inevitable Deus ex Machina. And you know what? All of those responses are perfectly valid. I realize that, and I respect that.
    But like I said before, the type of story you want to write is the first decision to make, and when you're sharing a thread with those who have a different type their writing, things can get frustrating.
    A lot of this, I think, could have been avoided if the staff had opened some OOC threads a few days before the actual invasion. Sure, it might have ruined the surprise, but it would have given them a chance to lay out what sort of story they wanted to tell, and give us all a chance to discuss with each other what sort of things we ourselves wanted to do with the event. I can speak for my own experience that the difference between "You cheap cheater!" and "Well Played, sir!" is one OOC thread or exchange of PM's.
    I think by now we're kind of over an awkward hump, and starting to figure out just what sort of stories these threads are actually supposed to be, and I'm able to have my fun with them again. I just think that with a little more forethought... well, what the heck, I'll say it:
    "THE FUN COULD HAVE BEEN DOUBLED!"
  2. PrinceBlueblood
    [colour=#444444]
    I’ve been a fan of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic from Season 1, and I’ve encountered the idea, more than once, that it was somehow evil or anti-Christian for a guy like me to like and be a fan of a show about pastel equines. Lately, I’ve come to realize the exact opposite was true.[/colour][colour=#444444]
    See, I’ve given a lot of thought these past few seasons on what it was exactly that made me like My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic so much. It is a well-made animated show, but it’s not alone in this respect. Yet, of all the gems of children’s entertainment, nothing resonated so much with as this one little show about colourful equines. And now, I think I know why.[/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    The conclusion I’ve come to is this: that it, in many ways, mirrors my own Faith and worldview. If I had to explain how my belief in Christ affected my view of the world, I could use MLP:FiM as an effective object lesson.[/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    The central concept of the show is Friendship, that is, of making and cultivating a meaningful relationship with someone else. That idea of a relationship is also central to the Universe, and of God Himself. He, being three Persons in One God, knew that Love, that comradeship, which was central to all true joy, and wished to make beings that he could share it with. We, as humans, were made to be the Friends of God![/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    It is a hard idea to comprehend, that, especially when we have so much trouble with our relations to other people. The truth is, we are Luna; jealousy, meanness, and all manner of general rottenness of temperament and character have ruined our relationship with God, and continue to wreak havoc whenever we try to deal with our fellow human beings. This miasma, often called sin, has made us from what we were mean to be into something worse, a Nightmare.[/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    But though we are fallen, though we are banished even farther than from the Earth to the Moon, God no more hates us than Celestia hated Luna. All He wants is to have us back, to return us to what we were meant to be. What had to be done to accomplish this, of course, differs between the show and reality. Here, we are made new by God the Son, Jesus’, own blood and sacrifice; but the purpose is parallel. He wants to forgive us, if we will accept; He wants to give us the chance to know Him, His Friendship.[/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    I feel that I could, if I continued in this vein, trace other parallels. How each “special talent,” unique but held equal in esteem and importance, parallel the idea of Spiritual Gifts. How the coming together of Unicorns, Pegasi, and Earth Ponies as equals under one banner parallels the fact that “There is neither Jew nor Greek, neither Slave nor Free in Christ.” The brony community itself, standing against cultural mores of the world, is even one; Christianity also grew, and perhaps was never so pure in its faith, as when it the entire Roman world against it.[/colour]
    [colour=#444444]
    Well, the bronies now know what a schism is; what disputes and arguments and pettiness and divisiveness can do to spoil a community. Pretty much the same stuff has corrupted the Church as an institution, to the point where it could take lessons from the show. Ah, but none of us are perfect; like the Mane Six, we have our faults and fatal flaws, and all need to learn, and be reminded, of what’s really important. Thank God that He is a Faithful teacher![/colour]
  3. PrinceBlueblood
    There was a lot of good stuff in this episode, I have to say, but it suffered, really suffered, from being 45 minutes long instead of an hour. Development of characters and concepts had to be compressed into sentences, giving it overall a very rushed feel. The framework holds up on retroactive inspection, but if you missed anything, you're probably going to be crying foul at developments that you missed the foreshadowing for. It doesn't actually end on a deus ex machina, but by golly, you'll think it did for a minute.
    To discuss the cybermen reboot on a separate note... yeah, they're made scary, but the thing is, I'm still wondering why they didn't keep using some of their tactics in the climax that they demonstrated in the set-up (You'll see which one I mean in particular). But Gaiman does use them creatively, I will admit.
  4. PrinceBlueblood
    War, War,
    She's a refugee,
    Things went wrong,
    Left no choice but to flee.
    War, War,
    She's a refugee,
    But her momma say one day
    She's gonna live in Equestria.
    In the sunrise,
    She is waiting,
    Waiting for a ship to come,
    Come for her. (Comfort Her)
    War, War,
    Her people go to war,
    They put up a fight
    But only last one day.
    War War,
    Scattered to the wind,
    But her momma say one day
    They're gonna come back from far away.
    A heart beats,
    Can you feel her heart beat?
    In the evening,
    She is waiting,
    For somepony to come,
    To help her take a stand,
    And lead her to this Promised Land!
    War, War,
    She's a pretty face,
    But in the wrong time,
    in the wrong place.
    War, War,
    She's a pretty face,
    Her momma says one day
    She's gonna live in Equestria
    Yeah,
    Equestria
    War, War,
    She's starved for love again,
    Don't even know how to be a friend.
    War, War,
    None must know what she is,
    Her momma say one day,
    She's gonna live in Equestria.
    (Original for comparison: http://youtu.be/HFdoogwXB3s)
×
×
  • Create New...