Sweet Luna, this book was horrendous! 1. Twilight doesn't act like herself. (Well, she does, but that dialogue where she said yuck after Cadence told Twi about her having a crush on Shining made me yell out loud, WHAT? That is so immature!) 2. Cadences backstory was awful. 3. Random appearance from Gilda and Best Pony. WORKING TOGETHER? Best Pony would be like "The Great and Powerful Trixie would not volunteer in such petty pranks!" And walk away. 4. They treat Gilda as a regular bully, BUT SHE ONLY APPEARED IN ONE EPISODE! 5. Canon Alicorn Twilight, automatically bad in my book. 6. They don't have proper references to Derpy. They just mention a muffin eating Pegasus, and don't call her Derpy. 2/10. One point for appearance of Best Pony, and one for a MLP chapter book existing