Jump to content
  • entries
    20
  • comments
    26
  • views
    59,226

XanXeto

460 views

 Share

So, I was thinking: Twilight has been a alicorn for a while now, correct? I'm just going to bust it out now; she's going to be living a very miserable life.

Why do I say that, you ask? Think about it. Just like Celestia and Luna, she's going to live forever (or a very long time at least) and she's going to watch her friends grow up, grow old, and die; yet she will still be alive and well.

Now I know what you're thinking at this point; Xan, that's terrible to think of. It is, it really is, but it's true. I wonder, did Celestia and/or Luna have any close friends growing up, or did they know at a young age that it was their fate to watch the ponies of Equestira grow and change and die? To watch the world grow and change, never to be the same as it once was.

When it gets late, I think of this stuff all the time; the bad side of everything.

Of course Twilight could always make new friends, but those will grow up and pass away as well in time(Hopefully due to old age and not by another incident).

These are my thoughts, leave me a comment on what you all think.

- Xan

 Share

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

This has been talked about since someone first thought that Twilight could become an Alicorn. A character that's defined by friendship, gradually looses all of her friends. The same thing can be said for Cadance, a character that's defined by love outlives the love of her life. This makes for good speculation and fan fiction, but its not something the show would ever cover. However, people have bugged asked the show's writers about this issue. This is how Meghan McCarthy responded.

http://www.equestriadaily.com/2013/04/twilight-sparkle-wont-outlive-her.html

Its possible that Celestia and Luna are the only immortal alicorns, and any others will have a normal lifespan. But again, this is all speculation, as we'll never actually know.

Link to comment

I'm not convinced it's as bad as it sounds. Yes, Twilight will likely continue to live while the friends of hers that we have come to know will pass on, but the thing is she will make new friends. And they will pass on, and more friendships will be formed, etc. So, to say that all of Twilight's friends will pass on is not to say that she will lose all her friends, and I could easily see the gains making the losses bearable.

I have lived through the deaths of several beloved, pet cats. Unless something goes catastrophically wrong, I will live through the death of at least one more, likely several. Maybe I'm being presumptuous in comparing the two cases, but I've found that the companionship provided to me and the good I can do for them generally outweighs the knowledge that I will have to watch their last moments, painful as they may be.

Link to comment

I see you point there Ravener, and I read the post on the forum Carsair, valid points, all of them.

However, the forum made me think. What defines an immortal alicorn? Is Twilight immoral or not? If not, is it because she became an alicorn and not born one like Celetsia and Luna?

I'm actually going to post theory #2 very soon on the "What if she is indeed immortal."

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...