Jump to content

elsporko

Members
  • Posts

    620
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by elsporko

  1. Discord is based on Q, but that doesn't change the fact that Discord can straight up mind control ponies. Despite being based on Q Discord follows different rules.

    Take as an example Frankenstein's monster from the book and the way the creature is depicted in movies. In the book the creature is intelligent and malicious, in many of the movies it is unintelligent and misunderstood. You have to take each one on its own since despite the movies being based on the book they are not the same character

  2. I see the similarities, but the story is generic enough I wouldn't call it a rip off or homage.

    Fun fact: According to the novelization of Gremlins Mogwai are aliens created to spread the message of love through the universe but turn evil because they were released before adequate testing could prove they turned into monsters. Intergalactic quality control could have prevented that entire disaster

  3. You can't bring up a character and the rules that apply to him to justify the actions of a different character played by the same actor. Discord is explicitly shown to be able to control ponies, not only was Fluttershy straight up mind controlled but Big Macintosh and Granny Smith appeared to be fully changed as well, unless constant dancing and being a dog are parts of their personality in some way.

    Whether or not the characters behaved in an evil fashion after being mind controlled is not the question, the initial attack, violation, and manipulation itself is an evil act. He made them all jerks, but he could have made them all super nice and with the mental capacity of a toddler, it would still have been an evil act.

    You can argue that Discord has to act a certain way due to his nature. Personally I think he was lucid enough and had enough self control that he could have taken part in his chaos creating ways in a less destructive fashion, but he either didn't care or enjoyed causing misery. I view Discord as a sociopath, he is very charming but cares only about his own enjoyment. We call a person who murders for enjoyment evil, evil if there is something that made them born that way, and Discord is in the same boat.

  4. I'm not sure how anybody could say he was good. He is basically the poster child for evil. He did things for his own benefit with no regard to how much he was hurting others, despite being well aware he was hurting them. Discord is an interesting character, but you can find a character interesting without trying to defend their actions

    • Like 1
  5. hi hi

    I can understand there would be any number of circumstances where returning the egg would be impossible. I also wish they'd have at least made some mention to how they weren't able to find the parents again or something, but I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt on that one.

    I know returning an egg to a nest of real birds that have abandoned the nest would be next to impossible, but since phoenixes are pretty smart, I don't know if that would be the case here. Maybe phoenixes are known for disappearing to distant lands unknown for 500 years after they're done nesting? Thats something Twilight might have read in a book... just would have been nice to get even a one sentence nod to a reason in the dialogue.

    As for dragons and aging. They're still not very clear on how Dragons operate, even after this episode and Secret of my Excess. I've been getting the impression that there is something magic about the way Dragons grow, since magic is what hatched Spike, and he likes to eat gems (which seem to have some kind of magic significance.) When Spike first hatched, he was a lot smaller than he is now, so it seems that dragons do have some sort of natural growth rate.

    I would guess that dragons grow to a certain point, at which they need to aquire treasure to continue grow. This would explain dragon's greed, they need to be greedy to grow stronger.

    Its also possible Spike gained enough greed between being a baby and his current point to grow as much as he has

  6. Oh Good! I'm not the only one who thinks so (pity this episode didn't have a random Spike & Scootaloo duet)

    Hmmm, Interesting point, I actually thought of it as being a bi-cultural/multi-cultural identity story; often when someone comes from one culture and grows up outside of it, for a while they won't give their genetic culture a thought but then will reach a point where they want to know everything they possibly can about it some even to the point that they become almost a stereo-type of that culture but eventualy they learn to balance all the cultures they belong to

    And I think that part of the teenage Dragons' problem is a surplus of testosterone or whatever the Dragon evquivilent is, raging hormones mess up a brain like nopony's buisiness

    Hmm, maybe Spike is part Pony, after all he was born from Unicorn Magic

    While not adopted myself I work with troubled teenagers. There have been a few black or black and white mixed who despite growing up in our predominatrly white area by white families that adopted them have trouble knowing how to act because they are dark skinned and think they need to act that part. I remember one in paticular who always associated with his biological family and constantly tried to connect with them despite the fact that they wanted nothing to do with him while the adopted family went mostly ignored for a long time

  7. I don't know about this episode. Lots to like about it, but also, some of it left me confused.

    SO, the 'Great Dragon Migration' is all about a bunch of dragons flying away just to sit around a huge crater?

    And if the 'teenage' dragons were all bullies, why wasn't all the BIGGER dragons bullying THEM too?

    And since when do all the dragons pile their gems together in one pile and let other dragons play with them?

    Spike found out the hard way that DRAGONS DON'T SHARE (in 'Owl's Well That Ends Well')

    Ok, I know this is just a cartoon, but still.....

    Not the WORST MLP ep I've seen, but definitely not the BEST, that's for sure....

    :D:D:D:D

    My guess is the dragons get together for either the purpose of breeding, or possible just so the younger dragons can interact with each other to develope their dragony talants. The adult dragons aren't involved because it would be pointless. The young dragons are play fighting, like the young of many predetor species. All their games are designed to help them develop talants they need as adults. Its practice and excersise disguised as games. The older dragons don't need practice and would only dominate the younger ones. Dragons might be greedy, but not to the point of their species going extict

    • Like 1
  8. I am rather in support of the Assad regime as the lesser of two evils.

    Information in Syria, like information in Libya, is being well distorted. Neither were popular revolutions by the people, but were instead foreign funded coups guised as democracy movements. All support to the Arab Socialist Party.

    Surely you aren't suggesting they were started by the same outside power, because considering the difference in world wide response it would seem they wouldn't have the same conspirators behind them

  9. I found this board while searching for another board of the same name and signed up for it out of curiosity. It looks like a fairly busy forum and that is nice. I've been on the search for a new place to forum online ever since a nasty series of misunderstanding resulted in me no longer being able to visit my last forum of choice, and I'll be darned if I'm going to do work while at work and not talk on the internet.

  10. I went to McDonalds because of a rumor they had Rainbow Dash. When the person was getting the toys my lady thought she saw Fluttershy in the box, but it was totally a Lilly Blossom which severely disappointing me because I am only interested in the show ponies not the random ones plus Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy would have both been the best ponies to get only furthering disappointment

×
×
  • Create New...