Hi there! I am not an RP-Helper and i am not that experienced with critique. I´ve read your app and since you asked for a reply, i shall be the first one. I am not a native English speaker, hope that is ok for you. First of all, i like your character. But i think some details are missing or should get a better description. describe your motivation with more detail. Why exactly does Lonely Shadow want to hear the tunes of Mr. Colt-trane? What is his dream? Is there something else he wants to achieve? If he wants to hear the music of Mr. Colt-trane again, why won´t he go back to Fillydalphia? What is your characters relationship to Mr. Colt-trane? Was he like a friend? Or a father? How many years did your character spend on his side? If his motivation is to hear tunes from him why did he leave him? What does your character like or dislike? Is there something your character is very good at, or does he have any flaws? I read your story now, but i have not found anything that would describe your characters personality. Whats your character like? Is he friendly, hasty, social, couraged? How does your character react to something new or unexpected? If another pony would meet your character for the first time, what would be the first impression? If you don´t have a character picture, just go here and have fun: Pony Creator I hope that i could help you with some ideas. I don´t know how long it will take that a real rp-helper shows up because i´m waiting for one like you. ^^ Iron Wing