Jump to content

Hurt/Heal WAR! Who is Best Pony?


Recommended Posts

Phil, Why do you hate Fluttershy so much?! raritysad.png

Well, to be honest, I don't actually hate her. :/

Of the mane six, she's the one I find the least interesting. To me, she just doesn't seem quite as deep and compelling a character as the others; most her episodes seem to reduce to the same basic themes and elements more so than the rest, and it seems to me sometimes that she gets by a lot just on her cuteness.

It's really not hate though. She is cute, and has had some really fun, humorous moments, and some good episodes centered on her (my favorites for her are Green Isn't Your Color and Putting Your Hoof Down). I like her character okay. She's just not one of the ponies I necessarily want to see win. :)

Link to comment

She's just not one of the ponies I necessarily want to see win. :)

Ergo you hate her xD

Joking, but well, I do believe there are other ponies out there you wouldn't like to see win too, but you'd still like to see Fluttershy win above them. So there must be some certain reasons for which you attack her ^^

Anyway, since new day started at 7:00AM for me usually, I guess it's a NEW DAY!

Link to comment

Twilight Sparkle: 56 ( 56 MAX) -powered up

Rarity: 59 (66 MAX) - powered up

Pinkie Pie: ELIMINATED

Rainbow Dash: 49 -powered up

Fluttershy: 41 -powered up

Applejack: 60 (60 Max) -powered up

Applebloom: 30

Sweetie Belle: 31

Scootaloo: 29

Princess Celestia: ELIMINATED

Princess Luna: 67.5 (70 Max) -powered up

Princess Cadence: 44 -powered up

Queen Chrysalis: 32

Discord: ELIMINATED

The Great and Powerful Trixie: 20

The Mayor: ELIMINATED

Pinkamena (crazy Cupcake Pinkie) : 36

Psycho Twilight (Lesson Zero Twilight) : 32

Cheerilee: 30

Braeburn: 28

Soarin: ELIMINATED

Spitfire: 39

Fancy Pants: 22

Derpy Hooves: 30

Doctor Whooves: 18

Lyra: 69 (69 MAX) -powered up

Bon-Bon: 50 -powered up

Vinyl Scratch: 55 (55 Max) -powered up

Octavia: 56 (56 Max) -powered up

Granny Smith: 28

Big Machitosh: 31

Berry Punch: 29

Mrs Cake: 30

Mr. Cake: 29

Pound Cake: 27

Pumpkin Cake: 29

Powerup:

Octavia 2

Vinyl Scratch 2

Twilight Sparkle 1

Lyra 1

Luna 2

Fluttershy 2

Hex:

Luna 4

Fluttershy 4

Bon-Bon 1

Doctor Whooves 2

Link to comment

The above count was slightly off (Rarity's hurt points were counted at full value rather than half and a few other small issues). Here's my count (with the last couple votes added in).

Twilight Sparkle: 56 ( 56 MAX) -powered up

Rarity: 62 (66 MAX) - powered up

Pinkie Pie: ELIMINATED

Rainbow Dash: 49 -powered up

Fluttershy: 41 -powered up

Applejack: 60 (60 Max) -powered up

Applebloom: 30

Sweetie Belle: 31

Scootaloo: 29

Princess Celestia: ELIMINATED

Princess Luna: 68.5 (70 Max) -powered up

Princess Cadence: 44 -powered up

Queen Chrysalis: 32

Discord: ELIMINATED

The Great and Powerful Trixie: 20

The Mayor: ELIMINATED

Pinkamena (crazy Cupcake Pinkie) : 36

Psycho Twilight (Lesson Zero Twilight) : 32

Cheerilee: 24

Braeburn: 28

Soarin: ELIMINATED

Spitfire: 39

Fancy Pants: 12

Derpy Hooves: 30

Doctor Whooves: 18

Lyra: 69 (69 MAX) -powered up

Bon-Bon: 50 -powered up

Vinyl Scratch: 55 (55 Max) -powered up

Octavia: 56 (56 Max) -powered up

Granny Smith: 28

Big Machitosh: 31

Berry Punch: 29

Mrs Cake: 30

Mr. Cake: 29

Pound Cake: 27

Pumpkin Cake: 29

Powerup:

Octavia 2

Vinyl 2

Twilight 2

Lyra 1

Luna 2

Fluttershy 4

Hex:

Luna 4

Fluttershy 4

Bon Bon 2

Doctor Whooves 2

Rarity 1

Currently Powered up ponies take half damage.

Link to comment

Ergo you hate her xD

Joking, but well, I do believe there are other ponies out there you wouldn't like to see win too, but you'd still like to see Fluttershy win above them. So there must be some certain reasons for which you attack her ^^

Anyway, since new day started at 7:00AM for me usually, I guess it's a NEW DAY!

Part of it is that she's the mane six who's my least favorite. Her status as one of the primary characters of the show makes her more threatening. Sure, I could go for characters I care less about, but I kind of doubt ponies like the Cake twins or Braeburn have any chance of winning this. As a main character, Fluttershy has a real chance, so she's just higher priority to me.

And sure there are characters who are probably more threatening to my favorites (Rarity, AJ and Chrysalis) in this thing, but I kind of love Luna, Lyra, Bon Bon, Octavia, Vinyl and Twilight. I wouldn't be able to complain too much if any of them won this thing.

That's the troubling thing about a game like this for a show like FIM, at least with me. I can honestly say I really like at least 90 percent of the characters in the show (and most of the ones I don't like aren't on the list), so when pitted against each other I may end up going aggressively after characters I don't really mind as much.

And speaking of which, today's votes:

Heal:

Chrysalis +5

Hurt:

Doctor Whooves -1

Hex:

Fluttershy x2

Link to comment

Um... I'm pretty sure that Luna's Power Up and Hex votes are equal. Let me quote that, starting from when the last Power Up and Hex went into affect.

She had 2 hex from Davroth (the first votes counted in the new Hex/powerup totals) and 2 hex from Villefort at the top of the page.

She's only had two power up votes on the other hand, provided of course by you. :)

Link to comment

Why all the sudden hate on Doctor Whooves? :shock:

In my case, I'm not sending hurt points toward Fluttershy at the moment (just hexes instead) since they'll only count for half. I could have sent my mandatory one hurt point toward any number of ponies. Mostly picked Doctor Whooves because he's already kind of low, and he's, quite frankly, never been a character I've really cared much about. Perhaps its my lack of any interest in Doctor Who or perhaps its just that he's a stallion, but he's one of the fandom favorites that's never really done anything for me. :/

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...